Top 5 Best Teeth Whitening Toothpastes & Dental Gels of 2024

Updated: Nov 19th, 2024

Gel versus Paste: Which One is Best for Your Teeth?

When choosing an oral care product to clean your teeth, there are more aspects to consider than brand, flavor, or price. Although toothpaste is the most commonly chosen formula for daily dental hygiene, those worried about preserving their enamel may consider a switch after finishing this article.

Differences Between Tooth Gel and Paste

Of course, the main difference between tooth gel and toothpaste is the consistency of the formula itself. While there are options on the market for combination gel and paste products, oftentimes people will choose one or the other. Here are some of the main differences between these two types of dentifrice:

Is One More Effective Than the Other?

One common rumor surrounding tooth gel vs. paste is that toothpaste does a better job of cleaning your teeth because the aftertaste lasts longer and the foamy texture creates a false sense of security when it comes to our brushing techniques. Unfortunately, a minty mouth and foamy texture does not guarantee good dental health.

That being said, which formula is the most effective at cleaning your smile?

Both toothpaste and tooth gel are effective manners of brushing your teeth, although, people with weak or thinning enamels should be wary of paste. The act of brushing develops a foamy texture and this foam tends to wear away at tooth enamel which can lead to tooth decay.

As for tooth gel, its thin consistency has a gentler impact on tooth enamel. In addition to this, gel-based formulas are great options for kids as their ingredients contain less chemicals that scrape the natural minerals on their growing teeth. Because of these factors, tooth gel is often recommended for those with enamel defects and sensitive teeth or gums.

Our Top 5 Picks of Whitening Toothpastes & Gels

These days there is a seemingly endless amount of toothpastes and tooth gels on the market. There are the big brands like Colgate, Oral B and Crest who are coming up with even more inventive kinds of toothpaste than ever, and then you have a lot of interesting smaller brands bringing their offering to the table with novel flavors and patented micro technologies.

We wanted to set the record straight on which toothpaste & tooth gel is actually the best so our team compared a whopping 25 different toothpastes over the course of 90 days and ranked them based on factors such as how much they cost, whether they were good value for money, what ingredients did they contain and whether they did what they said they would. The results were surprising as many of the independent brands outranked the top brands used around the worldwide and one in particular, LivFresh Dental Gel, stood out among the competitors. Here’s our ultimate list of the top 5 toothpastes!

Save Up to 50%

9.8

4.8/5

"Excellent"

3,639 Reviews

Crest Pro-Health Gum

9.4

4.4/5

"Great"

1,933 Reviews

Oxyfresh Premium Pro

9.3

4.3/5

"Cool"

1,287 Reviews

Silver Biotics Tooth Gel

8.9

3.8/5

"Good"

522 Reviews

NutriBiotic

8.1

3.4/5

"Not bad"

421 Reviews

Save Up to 50%

9.8

4.8/5

"Excellent"

3,639 Reviews

Things to Consider When Buying a Toothpaste & Dental Gel

When you’re choosing the perfect product that you’re going to use twice per day for many years it makes sense to ensure that it checks all of your boxes so you can be fully sure you’re getting exactly what you want from the toothpaste or dental gel. With so many independent brands on the market these days the very first thing to check is to see if the product is approved by the American Dental Association.

From there you need to choose whether you want the regular fluoride versions of toothpaste or want to opt for something more natural. Lots of people are turning away from fluoride toothpaste now that there are products like LivFresh Dental Gel available which have 100% edible ingredients like natural gums, stevia and peppermint. Artificial flavorings and colorings are falling out of popularity at a quickening pace in favor of organic and healthier options.

It’s often tempting to buy a specific toothpaste that claims to do one thing better than anything else if you are suffering from that issue. For example, it’s great to get a whitening toothpaste but if it’s not going to keep your gums in good health then you’re missing out. The ingredients in these specialist toothpastes don’t vary very much at all, the biggest difference is in the branded packaging that these big companies use.

As we’ve been testing these products for 90 days we can definitely say that the flavor and texture of a toothpaste or gel is super important. Some of our team had to stop using certain products after just a week because of a flavor that was not appealing or gels that turned slimy in your mouth. One last thing to mention is that it’s more cost-effective to buy a toothpaste that all the family can use from the youngest to the older instead of buying specialist kids toothpastes.

Test Results

Of all the toothpastes we tested only 5 made the cut into our top list, and at the top of that chart was LivFresh Dental Gel. When we use a toothpaste we just want to know that it is going to be a good all rounder and that’s what we found was possibly with LivFresh Dental Gel.

We want tartar and plaque eradicated, tooth enamel restored, fresh breath and strong healthy gums. We also need to be sure that when we visit the dentist that there aren’t going to be any painful fillings and root canals needed because we haven’t looked after our teeth properly with the right toothpaste or dental gel.

The first thing to note is that LivFresh Dental Gel was the best tasting of all the products we tested and it also had the most pleasant texture. Even though it was a gel it still delivered a high quality of teeth cleaning and unlike pastes which can leave small bits in your mouth it dissolved well so we knew that it was giving its benefits to our gums, teeth and tongue.

This is probably because the ingredients used in LivFresh compared to other big brands like Colgate were natural and 100% edible. Just looking at the ingredients list on the back of the tube we immediately spotted ‘organic stevia root’ and ‘natural gums’ which gave us the confidence that it was going to be doing good rather than 20 or 30 chemical names that we couldn’t even pronounce.

So if you’ve been considering switching your toothpaste there’s never been a better time to do it because LivFresh is now offering 50% off for a limited time. If you have a large family then it’s a good idea to take advantage of the multipack savings discount like the Family Fresh Bundle which includes 4 tubes of LivFresh Dental Gel to last a family of 4-6 for many months.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases from Amazon.com. You can learn more about our editorial policies here.

LINKS